What is UGC, and does it deserve part of your ad budget?
I read what IAB and Deloitte report on creator advertising, what peer-reviewed studies found, and what the FTC and the platforms require.
On this page
The short answer
UGC means content made by real people rather than a brand. Brands use it two ways: customers' own posts, and creator-made videos a brand pays for and runs as ads. Money is moving toward creators: IAB puts US creator ad spend at $37 billion in 2025, up 26%. But a peer-reviewed meta-analysis found brand-made content had the stronger effect on brand loyalty in most relationships, so I treat UGC as a tool for certain jobs, not a rule. That is what I found after reading the sources below.
Key takeaways
- UGC means two things: content customers make themselves, and creator-made videos a brand pays for, licenses and runs as its own ads.
- IAB projects US creator ad spend of $37 billion in 2025, up 26% and nearly 4x faster than the media industry's growth.
- Deloitte found 63% of Gen Zs and 49% of millennials say social media ads or reviews influence their purchases most, against 28% and 25% for streaming video ads.
- The evidence for UGC is weaker than the marketing claims: a meta-analysis of 223 samples found brand-made content had the stronger effect on brand loyalty in most relationships.
- Paid creators must disclose the relationship, and the FTC says its focus usually falls on advertisers or their agencies.
- A creator owns their video unless a contract or work-for-hire rule says otherwise, and TikTok requires the creator's authorization to run their post as an ad.
What does UGC actually mean?
It means two different things, and mixing them up causes most of the confusion. I use it here for both.
User-generated content (UGC) is content made by people outside a brand's own marketing team. One kind is organic: a customer posts a photo, a video or a review on their own. The other kind is paid: a brand hires a creator to shoot a video that looks like something a real customer filmed, licenses it, and runs it as its own ad. Softlixx sells that second kind, so I have a stake in this topic, and I have kept the evidence that cuts against it in.
The line between the two matters because the rules differ. The FTC's questions and answers say that when a business features consumer reviews in its advertising, they become testimonials, and the exemption for review hosting does not apply to them.
| Kind | Who makes it | What matters most |
|---|---|---|
| Organic UGC | A customer, unpaid | Featured in your ad, it counts as a testimonial (FTC). The creator owns it (U.S. Copyright Office), so you need permission. |
| Paid creator UGC | A creator, paid by the brand | The paid relationship must be disclosed (FTC). You need a licence, and on TikTok the creator's authorization. |
Sources: Federal Trade Commission (questions and answers), Federal Trade Commission (Disclosures 101), U.S. Copyright Office, TikTok Business Help Centre.
Are brands really moving budget to creators?
The numbers point that way, and the growth is fast. I read IAB's creator economy report and its video ad spend release.
IAB's 2025 Creator Economy Ad Spend and Strategy Report says US creator ad spend is projected to reach $37 billion in 2025, up 26% year over year and nearly 4x faster than the media industry's overall growth. It rose from $13.9 billion in 2021 to $29.5 billion in 2024, and IAB expects $44 billion in 2026.
US creator ad spend, billions of dollars (IAB)
Bars use a scale of 0 to 50 billion dollars. The 2025 and 2026 figures are IAB projections.
Source: IAB.
Buyers treat creators as a core channel. Nearly half (48%) of creator ad buyers consider creators a “must buy,” ranking them just behind paid search and social media. IAB's video ad spend release from May 2026 adds that social video, at 13%, now notably outpaces connected TV at 11%, helped by AI personalization and increased spend in the creator economy.
Brands increasingly treat creators not just as social media partners but as a full-fledged channel.
My readingIAB is an advertising industry group, and creator ad spend is a wider category than UGC-style ads. So I read this as a shift toward creators, not proof that UGC ads work better.
What do consumers say about creators and social ads?
Younger consumers say social media matters more to their buying than streaming ads. I read Deloitte's survey to see how much.
Deloitte's 19th annual Digital Media Trends survey, of 3,595 US consumers aged 14 and older fielded in October 2024, found that 56% of Gen Zs and 43% of millennials find social media content more relevant than traditional TV shows and movies. And 63% of Gen Zs and 49% of millennials say ads or product reviews on social media are most influential to their purchasing decisions. Only 28% of Gen Zs and 25% of millennials said that of streaming video ads. The survey asks about ads and reviews on social media, not UGC ads in particular.
Gen Zs: what they call most influential to their purchases (Deloitte)
Bars use a scale of 0 to 100%. 3,595 US consumers aged 14 and older, October 2024.
Millennials: what they call most influential to their purchases (Deloitte)
Bars use a scale of 0 to 100%.
Source: Deloitte US.
Does UGC work better than brand-made content?
Not always. The strongest evidence I found is a meta-analysis, and it points the other way from the marketing claims.
A meta-analysis in the Journal of Interactive Marketing combined 223 independent samples with a total of 97,709 respondents to compare user-generated and firm-generated social media content. It asked how qualities such as information quality, credibility, usefulness, positive emotions, interactivity and self-congruity affect brand loyalty.
The impact of the attributes on the brand loyalty dimension is stronger for firm-generated content than for user-generated content for most of the relationships.
The authors add that the effects depend on context: low or high involvement, hedonic or utilitarian products, durable or nondurable goods, and the social media platform. The study covers brand loyalty on social media, not paid video ads, and it was published in 2023.
A second study, a preprint of more than a million Instagram posts by 400 creators in four countries, looked at sponsored content. It concluded that sponsored posts have lower engagement on average, but properly disclosing ads does not reduce engagement further.
| Source | What it found | Limit to keep in mind |
|---|---|---|
| IAB creator report | US creator ad spend is rising fast: $37 billion projected for 2025. | It measures spending, not results, and covers more than UGC ads. |
| Deloitte survey | Younger consumers say social ads and reviews influence their purchases most. | It asks about social ads and reviews, not UGC ads. Survey fielded in October 2024. |
| Meta-analysis | The effect on brand loyalty is stronger for brand-made content in most relationships. | It studies loyalty on social media, not paid video ads. Published in 2023. |
| Instagram preprint | Sponsored posts get lower engagement, and disclosure does not lower it further. | A preprint about creators' own posts, not brand ads. |
Sources: IAB, Deloitte US, Journal of Interactive Marketing, arXiv.
My readingSo the honest answer is that it depends on the job. When I searched for UGC statistics, the first results were blogs from companies that sell UGC tools or services, and I did not use their figures because I could not trace them to a study.
What must a brand disclose, and whose permission does it need?
Disclose paid relationships, and get permission for the video. Both come from published rules and platform pages.
The FTC's Disclosures 101 says an endorsement should make it obvious when there is a “material connection” with the brand. That includes a financial relationship such as the brand paying you or giving you free or discounted products or services. The disclosure should be placed so it is hard to miss, and not mixed into a group of hashtags or links.
Responsibility does not stop with the creator. In its Endorsement Guides questions and answers, the FTC says where it would focus.
If law enforcement becomes necessary, our focus usually will be on advertisers or their ad agencies and public relations firms.
The FTC's 2024 rule on fake reviews also covers testimonials that misrepresent that they are by someone who does not exist, such as AI-generated fake reviews.
Platforms build the label into their tools. On YouTube, selecting the paid promotion button adds a disclosure label at the beginning of the video, and YouTube says creators and the partners they work with are responsible for complying with all applicable legal requirements.
Permission works the same way. The U.S. Copyright Office says that once you create an original work and fix it, you are the author and the owner, and ownership can also come from contracts like assignments, or from work for hire rules for certain commissioned works. TikTok's Spark Ads page, last updated in June 2026, says brands can publish ads using organic posts made by other creators with their authorization, and lets the length of the authorization be customized.
If the creator is an AI avatar, different rules apply. I cover them in AI-generated video ads and disclosure.
My readingI read this as one rule of thumb: put the paid relationship, the licence and the ad's claims in writing before the video runs. I am not a lawyer, and these are US rules and platform pages, so ask one about the countries you advertise in.
How do I know if UGC is working for me?
Measure it against your own numbers. The research does not give one answer, and IAB says measurement is a challenge.
IAB says growing investment has increased focus on challenges such as measuring business outcomes, choosing the right creators and understanding the role of AI, and that identifying the right creators is brands' top challenge. It also says creator campaigns most often seek awareness and reach, while sales is also among the top goals. TikTok's Spark Ads page lists metrics such as paid clicks, and says all of a Spark Ad's engagement is attributed to the original organic post.
How often to post organic content is a separate question, covered in the research on how often to post. How long each video ad should run is covered in the research on video ad length.
My readingSince the meta-analysis shows results depend on context, I would test on my own audience: the same offer in a creator-made video and a brand-made one, with the same budget and audience, judged on cost per sale or lead rather than likes.
What should a business do first?
If I were starting today, I would work in this order: pick the job, choose creators, sort out the paperwork, then test. It is my reading of the sources above.
- Decide the job firstIAB says creator campaigns most often seek awareness and reach, and sales is also a top goal. Pick one.
- Choose creators who fit the productIAB says identifying the right creators is brands' top challenge.
- Get the licence in writingThe creator owns the video unless a contract says otherwise. Write down where, how long and on which platforms you can run it.
- Disclose every paid relationshipUse the platform's paid promotion tool and a plain “ad” or “sponsored” label, which the FTC says is clear.
- Feature only real customer reviewsA review you run in an ad becomes a testimonial, and the FTC bans fake ones.
- Never fake a customer with AIThe FTC rule bans testimonials from people who do not exist, such as AI-generated fake reviews.
- Test against a brand-made adRun the same offer both ways and judge them on your own cost per result.
Questions people ask
What is UGC?
UGC is short for user-generated content: content made by people outside a brand's own marketing team. It covers customers' own posts and reviews, and creator-made videos that a brand pays for and runs as ads. The rules differ, so it helps to know which kind you mean.
Do I need permission to use a customer's post in my ads?
Generally, yes. The U.S. Copyright Office says the person who creates and fixes an original work is its author and owner, unless a contract or a work for hire rule says otherwise. The FTC also says reviews a business features in its advertising become testimonials. TikTok lets a brand run other creators' posts only with their authorization.
Do I have to disclose paid creators?
Yes, under US rules. The FTC says an endorsement should make it obvious when there is a material connection, such as the brand paying the creator or giving free products. YouTube adds a disclosure label when a creator selects paid promotion. If enforcement is needed, the FTC says its focus usually falls on advertisers or their agencies.
Does UGC perform better than brand-made ads?
The evidence I found is mixed. A meta-analysis of 223 samples found the effect on brand loyalty stronger for brand-made content in most relationships. Deloitte found younger consumers say social media ads and reviews influence their buying most. None of it is a direct test of UGC ads against brand ads, so I would test on my own audience.
Sources
- 2025 Creator Economy Ad Spend & Strategy ReportIAB. Published 20 November 2025.
- U.S. Digital Video Ad Spend to Surpass $80B in 2026IAB. Published 5 May 2026.
- A Competition for Consumer Attention: Are Social Platforms Overtaking Traditional Studios in Entertainment and Advertising?Deloitte US. Published 25 March 2025. Survey fielded October 2024.
- Understanding the Role of Social Media Content in Brand Loyalty: A Meta-Analysis of User-Generated Content Versus Firm-Generated ContentJournal of Interactive Marketing (University of Jyväskylä repository). Published 2023, Journal of Interactive Marketing 58(4), pages 400 to 413.
- Influencer Self-Disclosure Practices on Instagram: A Multi-Country Longitudinal StudyarXiv (preprint by Thales Bertaglia and colleagues). Submitted 12 July 2024.
- Disclosures 101 for Social Media InfluencersFederal Trade Commission. Documentation, read 28 September 2026.
- FTC's Endorsement Guides: What People Are AskingFederal Trade Commission. Documentation, read 28 September 2026.
- The Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule: Questions and AnswersFederal Trade Commission. Documentation, read 28 September 2026.
- Federal Trade Commission Announces Final Rule Banning Fake Reviews and TestimonialsFederal Trade Commission. Published 14 August 2024.
- Add branded content restrictions & disclosure labelsYouTube Help. Documentation, read 28 September 2026.
- About Spark AdsTikTok Business Help Centre. Last updated June 2026.
- What is Copyright?U.S. Copyright Office. Documentation, read 28 September 2026.
How I checked this. I opened every source linked here and checked each figure and each quotation against the source page, most recently on 3 October 2026. Anything in a box marked “My reading” is my own interpretation, not a finding of the studies. Studies change and new ones appear, so I will update this piece and change its dates when the evidence does.